Some people prefer their bananas yellow with a tinge of green, while others prefer the sugary sweetness of a banana that has brown spots on the peel.
But it’s not just the flavour that’s different, for there are distinctive effects on your body and health dependent on the ripeness …
Unripe, green bananas have been shown to have 20 times as much resistant starch as ripe bananas.
This is a form of starch which the body struggles to break down (it ‘resists’ the digestive process), so it passes straight through the gut.
This slows down the speed at which the carbohydrates in the fruit are converted into glucose and absorbed into the blood.
During ripening, the starch in a banana is converted into sugar — from 3.2g/100g in an unripe banana to 12g/100g in a ripe one
A green banana typically has a glycaemic index (GI) of 30, compared to 58 for a ripe banana.
Not only is resistant starch good for steadying your blood sugar levels, but ‘good’ bacteria in the colon also feed on it.
They, in turn, boost the digestive enzymes that help us digest carbs and absorb vitamins from food, as well as protect us against any unfriendly microorganisms.
Professor Gordon Carlson, a consultant gastric surgeon at Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust, told Good Health he eats one relatively unripe banana every day to boost his gut health. The benefits of green bananas were confirmed in a major review of 18 studies on their nutrition, published in the journal Nutrients in 2019.
This found that green bananas can help with gastrointestinal symptoms (such as diarrhoea and constipation) and diseases (such as intestinal cancers).
A green banana typically has a glycaemic index (GI) of 30, compared to 58 for a ripe banana
They may also assist in preventing or treating type 2 diabetes.
Unlike other foods, bananas contain a form of resistant starch that is increased, rather than degraded, by heating.
In fact, one study published in the Malaysian Journal of Nutrition in 2018 found boiling green bananas increased their resistant starch content.
Other research has shown that chilling cooked green bananas in the fridge increases resistant starch by a further 50 per cent.
The cooling process causes the starches to form a new structure which is even more resistant to digestion (called ‘starch retrogradation’).
During ripening, the starch in a banana is converted into sugar — from 3.2g/100g in an unripe banana to 12g/100g in a ripe one.
‘This is what makes them a good source of quick release energy for athletes,’ says dietitian Dr Sarah Schenker.
The lower quantities of resistant starch also means yellow bananas are easier to digest. If you have digestive problems, green bananas can leave you feeling gassy or bloated.
Dr Schenker suggests the health benefits of yellow bananas trump those of green ones.
‘Bananas contain several compounds, such as carotenoids, which are linked to eye health and cancer prevention, and which become more “bioavailable” [available to the body] when the banana ripens,’ she says.
‘With less starch to break down, your digestive system will soak up the nutrients more quickly.’
Bananas contain B vitamins as well as the antioxidant vitamins A and C, plus the minerals iron, magnesium, manganese and potassium.
Some of these micronutrients are lost as the banana ages, but antioxidant levels, which help to support the immune system, reach a peak.
Studies, including one published in 2014 in the International Food Research Journal, have shown that vitamin C levels increase with the ripening process, but decline as the banana becomes overripe.
‘These antioxidants exist to protect the fruit from being eaten and tend to rise as the fruit ripens,’ explains Dr Sangeetha Thondre, a senior lecturer in nutrition at Oxford Brookes Centre for Nutrition and Health.
Yellow with brown spots
The brown spots on a very ripe banana indicate that even more starch has been converted to sugar.
Scientists have found a fully ripe banana produces a substance called tumour necrosis factor (TNF) which has the ability to combat abnormal cells and boost our immunity against cancer.
In a study published in 2009 in the journal Food Science and Technology Research, scientists at Teikyo University in Japan found that bananas with dark spots were eight times more effective at enhancing the power of white blood cells (which fight infection) than green- skinned bananas.
They reported that the degree of the fruit’s anti-cancer effect corresponds to the degree of ripeness — the more patches a banana has, the greater its immunity-boosting power.
Bananas produce ethylene gas, a natural compound that regulates the ripening process, causing them to turn brown.
This changes their texture and flavour as well as their nutritional value. When a banana becomes overripe, much of the starch is converted into sugars, making it an excellent natural source of sweetness.
Dr Schenker recommends using brown bananas in baking and freezing them to whizz up in a blender to make sugar-free ice cream.
‘Using overripe bananas instead of sugar is a healthier way to sweeten food, as bananas
provide several essential nutrients: potassium, vitamin B6, folate and some vitamin C,’ she says.
Eventually, overripe bananas can start to ferment, losing many of their nutritional benefits. They might start to smell more like alcohol than sugar, and can contain up to 0.5g of alcohol per banana.
Laboratory studies have shown you can extract ethanol (alcohol) from extremely ripe bananas, but only after adding yeast and sugar.
Hot cross buns test
Here, Sophie Medlin, of City Dietitians in London, assesses various ‘healthier’ hot cross buns — and we then rated them.
Tesco Free From
4 x 70g buns, £2.20, tesco.com
Claim: ‘Gluten, wheat and milk free.’
Per bun: Calories 161; saturated fat 0.2g; sugar 12.2g; fibre 6.3g; protein 2.8g.
Verdict: A mix of gluten-free grains, fibrous psyllium husk and bamboo fibre, provides 21 per cent of your daily fibre. Butter and milk have been replaced with rapeseed oil and dried egg white.
Health rating: 8/10
Taste: Nice, sticky fruit and cinnamon, but very dry. 4/10
Seriously Low Carb
4 x 55g buns, £3.99, seriouslylowcarb.com
Claim: ‘A fraction of the carbs of a regular hot cross bun. High in protein and fibre.’
Per burn: Calories, 113; saturated fat 1.2g; sugar 4.2g; fibre 4.6g; protein 10.7g
Verdict: Using a reduced-carb, protein-rich wheat flour, these buns have 80 per cent less carbs than regular buns. The low-calorie sweetener erythritol may cause bloating.
Health rating: 6/10
Taste: Over-spiced; minimal fruit. 2/10
Seriously Low Carb
Sainsbury’s Be Good to Yourself
6x 70g buns, £1.10 sainsburys.co.uk
Claim: ‘Less than 3 per cent fat.’
Per bun: Calories 186; saturated fat 0.7g; sugar 11.6g; fibre 1.9g; protein 5g
Verdict: These have a few more calories and fat than some buns, and there are several ultra-processed ingredients.
Health rating: 2/10
Taste: Juicy but stodgy and a bit dry. 3/10
4 buns, £1.65 waitrose.com
Claim: ‘Made with wholemeal flour.’
Per bun: Calories 187; Saturated fat 1.5g; sugar 12.4g; fibre 4g; protein 6.7g
Verdict: Not quite as much extra fibre as you might expect, just 13 per cent of your daily needs — and three teaspoons of sugar, most of it coming naturally from the fruit, but also some dextrose.
Health rating: 6/10
Taste: Top quality fruit. 7/10